Propane provides more energy and heating efficiency per unit than natural gas. However, natural gas may be more economical and accessible in some areas. Learn the main differences to determine which is better for your home.
Natural gas and propane both serve as energy sources for heating, cooking, and other applications in homes and businesses. While they share some similarities, there are important differences between these two energy sources.
Natural gas is a naturally occurring hydrocarbon gas mixture, primarily composed of methane. Propane, often associated with LPG (liquefied petroleum gas), emerges as a by-product of natural gas processing and crude oil refining.
In residential settings, the gas utilised often contains a mixture of propane and butane.
Some key differences between natural gas propane include:
Within domestic environments, both propane and natural gas can power a variety of appliances, including furnaces, water heaters, stoves, fireplaces, and clothes dryers. Boasting energy efficiency, both fuels are clean-burning, with propane offering more flexibility in locations without natural gas pipeline infrastructure. Ultimately, deciding to fuel your home with either option hinges on their availability and the associated costs for one’s specific property.
As a non-renewable resource, natural gas develops deep underground over millennia from the decomposition of organic matter. It consists primarily of natural gas methane, with smaller amounts of other hydrocarbons like ethane, propane, and butane. The chemical structure of methane has one carbon atom bound to four hydrogen atoms.
Propane, however, with a chemical structure of three carbon atoms bonded to eight hydrogen atoms (C3H8), differentiates itself from methane. Compared to methane, propane has higher energy density, but requires pressurisation for storage and transportation as a liquid rather than a gas.
Although propane and natural gas can both function efficiently as fuel gases, propane necessitates additional processing to be practical for use. Comprehending their origins and chemical structures helps unravel key distinctions in using natural gas and propane as crucial energy sources.
Natural gas and propane have very different methods of storage and transportation:
Natural gas, in its gaseous state, is transported from production sites to consumers via a widespread network of pressurised pipelines. Natural gas pipelines transport the fuel directly to homes and businesses with no need for specialised storage on-site.
Unlike natural gas, propane is transformed into liquefied natural gas under pressure for more efficient transportation and storage. Propane is moved from refineries to bulk storage sites in pressurised tanks and subsequently distributed to consumers in portable tanks and cylinders. These propane tanks, similar to compressed natural gas CNG containers, can be stored above ground, underground, or even on rooftops for easy access.
The need for pressurisation and specialised tanks makes adopting propane systems more complex for homes and businesses not served by existing natural gas pipelines. However, propane also offers ease of portability which can make it a suitable option for remote properties without pipeline access.
The infrastructure required to deliver natural gas versus propane to homes and businesses differs significantly:
Natural gas requires an extensive pipeline network to deliver the fuel. Underground gas mains and service lines must be installed to transport natural gas from interstate pipelines into local utility distribution systems. From there, it travels through metre sets into homes and businesses for end use in appliances.
Propane relies on truck-based deliveries of pressurised tanks. No pipelines or permanent infrastructure are needed.
Bulk storage facilities accommodate substantial quantities of propane, which is then filled into small cylinders or sizeable tanks for on-site use. These pressurised tanks are delivered to homes and businesses, facilitating convenient on-site fuel access and storage.
Ultimately, natural gas delivery requires substantial infrastructure enabled by pipeline access. Propane offers an alternative for properties not served by pipelines, with transportable pressurised tanks providing on-site fuel storage as needed.
Propane requires on-site storage tanks, while natural gas typically does not. There are several options for safely storing propane fuel at homes or businesses:
Above-ground propane tanks are a popular choice for residential backup power systems. Smaller tanks need refilling more often.
Tanks can be leased from propane suppliers and are available in sizes from 120 to 1,000 US gallons.
For some residential and many commercial sites, it is preferable to install propane tanks underground. This provides security, frees up outdoor space, and has aesthetic advantages. Although more costly to install, underground tanks have a reduced risk of damage compared to above-ground alternatives.
Propane’s need for stored fuel gives it flexibility in remote areas but requires more planning for safe, long-term storage conditions than continuously flowing natural gas supplies.
BTU, or British Thermal Unit, is a standard measurement used to compare the energy content of fuels. Specifically, one BTU represents the amount of heat required to raise the temperature of one pound of water by one degree Fahrenheit.
On a BTU basis:
Consequently, propane has a substantially higher energy density, allowing more BTUs to be stored in a compact volume. You would need about 89 cubic feet of natural gas to equal the BTUs in one gallon of propane.
Appliances burn hotter with propane due to its greater BTU content per gallon, but they can be fine-tuned to work with either fuel source. For heating systems, propane’s energy density means smaller fuel storage volumes needed to heat spaces.
On the other hand, appliances using natural gas gain efficiency benefits from the stable pressure provided by gas pipelines. Both fuels are clean, efficient options for domestic and commercial use.
When comparing the costs of natural gas versus propane, there are several factors to consider:
Propane heating systems and appliances generally cost more than their natural gas counterparts. This is because propane systems require pressurised tanks, regulators, and other specialised equipment for on-site fuel storage and delivery.
The cost of propane often exceeds that of natural gas when measured per British thermal unit (BTU). However, propane prices can fluctuate more than natural gas. Regional supply and demand trends can cause propane prices to spike during high-draw seasons.
Installing new gas service lines can be expensive, and sometimes cost prohibitive for homes not already using natural pipelines. The flexibility of propane tank installations allows it to better serve remote properties.
Over the long term, natural gas enjoys a less expensive cost advantage for most residential uses. However, propane offers energy independence and can make sense for rural properties without pipeline access.
Ultimately, buyers should calculate total cost of ownership according to their needs. This means factoring in fuel costs, hardware prices, infrastructure requirements, and convenience.
Natural gas, being a natural gas lighter than air, disperses quickly and poses less risk of explosion when leaks occur. The issue of leaks highlights the critical safety considerations between propane, which can accumulate in low-lying areas as it is heavier than air. This means extra precautions are needed to prevent propane leaks in homes and businesses.
Both natural gas and propane burn cleanly with relatively low emissions when combusted efficiently. On a per-unit-of-energy basis, propane incurs a slightly smaller carbon footprint, and both fuels emit fewer CO2 emissions than numerous other fossil fuels due to their clean-burning properties.
Methane is a far more potent greenhouse gas than CO2 though. And leaks along natural gas infrastructure can release methane, contributing to climate change. More maintenance is needed to prevent methane slipping into the atmosphere.
Compared to fuels like heating oil or coal, both propane liquefied petroleum gas and natural gas are considered clean fuels. Propane, a by-product of gas processing, makes productive use out of what would otherwise emit greenhouse gases.
When combusted effectively, natural gas and propane offer environmentally friendly alternatives with lower emissions than oil or coal.
It is important to know how to detect leaks for both natural gas and propane systems.
Given that natural gas is lighter than air, its leaks tend to rise and disperse.
If a leak occurs, the gas will sink and puddle in low spots since propane vapour is heavier than air.
To detect leaks, a distinctive rotten egg smell is added to propane by suppliers through the inclusion of ethyl mercaptan. Use soapy water to test for leaks and bubbles. Since propane is naturally odourless, detecting leaks can be more challenging.
If you suspect a major natural gas or propane leak:
It’s essential to heed any signs of a gas leak, from the telltale odour to bubbling at the joints of pipes. Leave the premises and call emergency services for assistance.
When deciding between propane natural gas for your home, consider factors like:
Homes with existing natural gas lines and appliances may find it easiest to remain on the pipeline grid. Switching from natural gas to propane incurs additional expenses for new equipment and set-up. Remote properties without pipeline access, however, can benefit from the portability of propane delivery and storage.
Look at your household energy use - are you primarily using gas for heating and cooking? For space heating, propane furnaces can be an efficient choice, though natural gas boilers benefit from consistent pipeline pressure. Both fuels can supply ranges and outdoor amenities like pool heaters.
While propane tends to cost more upfront, natural gas bills can become expensive for high-demand households over time. Conduct a long-term financial analysis of both fuels before deciding to convert any appliances or equipment.
For Sydney-area homes interested in installing or converting to natural gas or propane systems, call Marrickville Plumbing to evaluate your options. Our qualified technicians can assess your needs and recommend the safest, most affordable fuel solutions for your household.
A simple household plunger uses water pressure to unclog pipes and drains. It’s ideal to try a plunger first on blocked sinks, showers and toilets before calling a plumber. Quickly and easily unblock your drain before problems worsen.
Read MoreIs your hot water pressure too low? There are various causes including blocked pipes, faulty valves and regulators, scale build-up and more. Our licensed Marrickville plumbers offer fast, affordable solutions to diagnose and boost hot water pressure throughout your home.
Read MoreHot water systems work by heating cold water in a tank or on demand as it flows through. Electric, gas and solar systems heat the water differently but all supply hot water when you need it. For professional installation, repairs or advice call our expert team on 1300 000 000.
Read MoreMarrickville, 2204 NSW
We will call back as soon as possible.
